Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, togetherness, and, of course, delectable feasts. When you find yourself in the vibrant paradise of Key West during this season, you’re in for a special treat. The Key West weather is perfect during the fall, and Key West is known not only for its relaxed vibe and unique culture but also for its culinary delights!
In this post, we’ll introduce you to five Key West restaurants that are open on Thanksgiving, offering mouthwatering dishes and a warm island welcome to create unforgettable holiday memories!
Cafe Marquesa
If you’re seeking a truly extraordinary Key West Thanksgiving dining experience, look no further than Cafe Marquesa. Situated in the heart of the historic district, Cafe Marquesa is a gem among the island’s dining establishments. Renowned for its fine dining and artistic culinary creations, it provides the perfect backdrop for an intimate and memorable Thanksgiving meal.
On Thanksgiving, Cafe Marquesa offers a special menu that elevates traditional favorites to gourmet heights. Expect a feast that includes roasted turkey with all the trimmings but with a creative twist. The sides are crafted to perfection, and the desserts are the epitome of sweet indulgence.
The atmosphere at Cafe Marquesa is elegant and cozy, making it an ideal choice for couples or small groups who wish to celebrate the holiday with a touch of sophistication. The historic charm of the restaurant, combined with the culinary artistry of its chefs, sets the stage for an unforgettable Thanksgiving dinner that you’ll cherish for years to come.
Martin’s
For a Thanksgiving celebration that’s family-friendly and relaxed, Martin’s is a perfect choice in the heart of Old Town, one of the most famous and historic Key West neighborhoods. Known for its welcoming atmosphere and a menu that showcases the flavors of the island, Martin’s offers a delightful twist on traditional Thanksgiving dishes.
On Thanksgiving, Martin’s serves up a special menu that combines the classic turkey and stuffing with the vibrant tastes of Key West. Picture a delicious roasted turkey with a local mango glaze or succulent Key West pink shrimp. These delectable dishes infuse the holiday with a touch of tropical flavor, creating a memorable culinary experience.
The restaurant’s atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a great place to celebrate Thanksgiving with family and friends. Whether surrounded by loved ones or seated at communal tables, Martin’s provides a welcoming and laid-back setting to enjoy a holiday feast. It’s the ideal choice for those who seek a Thanksgiving dinner with a touch of island spirit.
Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen
For a Thanksgiving celebration with a breathtaking waterfront view, look no further than the Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen at the Oceans Edge Key West Hotel & Marina. This restaurant offers an idyllic setting for a Thanksgiving lunch or dinner, allowing you to savor a meal while gazing at the sparkling waters.
At Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen, you can expect to indulge in dishes that spotlight the freshest seafood and locally sourced ingredients infused with the spirit of the Florida Keys. While they offer traditional Thanksgiving fare, you’ll also find signature dishes like Yellowfin Tuna Tataki, which add a delightful tropical twist to the holiday.
The restaurant’s picturesque waterfront location creates a tranquil ambiance, making it the ideal spot to celebrate Thanksgiving. Whether you’re seated indoors or on the outdoor terrace, you’ll be treated to stunning views that enhance the holiday experience.
Thanksgiving with a tropical touch? Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen delivers precisely that. It’s a wonderful choice for those who want to savor a flavorful Thanksgiving meal while enjoying the mesmerizing beauty of the Gulf of Mexico. So, whether you’re a seafood lover or simply seeking a unique Thanksgiving dining experience, Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen has all the ingredients for an unforgettable holiday celebration in Key West.
Plan Your Visit
Hoping to spend your Thanksgiving in paradise? Look no further than our wonderful Key West vacation rentals! Each of our rentals is equipped with everything you need for the perfect stay, plus they’re just moments away from the island’s top attractions, activities, and, most importantly, delicious local restaurants! Find your home away from home now and book your stay today!
Lighthouse Grill
For a Thanksgiving celebration with a touch of adventure, consider heading to the Lighthouse Grill, located in Marathon, the heart of the Florida Keys. This restaurant offers a delightful Thanksgiving experience that’s just a scenic drive away from Key West.
Located at the Faro Blanco Resort and Yacht Club, the Lighthouse Grill offers picturesque views of the Gulf of Mexico. On Thanksgiving, they pull out all the stops with a bountiful buffet that includes all the classics, from succulent roasted turkey to mouthwatering stuffing and pumpkin pie. It’s a true Thanksgiving feast that’s sure to satisfy your holiday cravings.
The restaurant’s nautical ambiance and captivating waterfront views create an inviting setting for celebrating the holiday with friends and family. It’s an ideal choice for those seeking to enjoy Thanksgiving with a blend of flavors and adventure that the Florida Keys have to offer.
Prime Steakhouse
If your ideal Thanksgiving celebration involves savoring succulent steaks and prime cuts, then the Prime Steakhouse in the heart of Key West is your destination. While not exclusively a Thanksgiving restaurant, Prime Steakhouse opens its doors for this special occasion, offering an a la carte menu that promises a gourmet experience.
Located in the historic district of Key West, Prime Steakhouse is renowned for its top-quality meats and an extensive wine list.
On Thanksgiving, you can enjoy a gourmet meal featuring some of the finest cuts, fresh seafood, and elegant sides. The restaurant’s ambiance is upscale and sophisticated, making it a suitable choice for couples or groups looking for a high-end Thanksgiving dinner.
The a la carte menu at Prime Steakhouse allows you to craft your Thanksgiving feast according to your preferences. Whether you prefer a perfectly cooked filet mignon or a sumptuous seafood dish, you’ll find a variety of choices that cater to your taste. Pair your meal with a selection from their excellent wine list to complete the experience.
Prime Steakhouse provides an elegant and gourmet approach to Thanksgiving dining in Key West. It’s the perfect destination for those who appreciate the finer things in life and wish to celebrate the holiday with the utmost culinary excellence.
Whether you’re a connoisseur of prime cuts or simply want to indulge in a luxurious Thanksgiving meal, Prime Steakhouse promises a memorable and tasteful holiday celebration.
Book your Key West Vacation Rental With Historic Hideaways
As you prepare to indulge in a Thanksgiving feast at one of Key West’s finest restaurants, don’t forget to secure The perfect Key West vacation rental with Historic Hideaways. Our selection of Key West house rentals is designed to ensure your stay on this beautiful island is both comfortable and memorable.
At Historic Hideaways, we offer a range of handpicked Key West rentals, each with its own character and style, to suit your preferences and make your Key West stay truly exceptional!
Whether you dream of a cozy historic cottage or a large reunion home, our rentals are built with everything you need for the ideal stay and tailored for your comfort. Many of our houses are available for weekly rental, so you can spend Thanksgiving week with us.
We understand that every vacation is a unique dream waiting to be realized, and our commitment is to provide you with the finest accommodations so you can fully immerse yourself in Key West’s magic. View all of our rentals in Key West today and make this Thanksgiving the best one yet!